Equitable distribution is the legal principle most states use to divide marital property in a divorce. In so-called equitable distribution or common law property states the court attempts to divide the spouses’ assets equitably (fairly) and may consider the value of a spouse’s separate property in making an unequal division of the spouses marital property.
In deciding what is an equitable distribution of the spouses’ property, the court may consider factors such as the relative education, employability, earning capacities, and separate property assets (acquired before marriage) of the spouses, and whether one spouse’s infidelity or abusive behavior, for example, was a greater factor in the breakup of the marriage.
In contrast, if the spouses live in a community property state the court generally begins with the presumption that the spouses’ marital or community property will be divided equally.
But in practice, the difference between the division of assets in community property states and in equitable distribution states is sometimes not as great as it may seem, as the court in a community property state may have the discretion to divide the spouses’ community property on a 60-40, 70-30, or other unequal basis—and to order one of the spouses to pay all or most of the community debts—based on factors such as the relative education, employability, earning capacities, and separate property assets (acquired before marriage) of the spouses, and whether one spouse’s infidelity or abusive behavior was a greater factor in the breakup of the marriage.
Community property states generally include Alaska, Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin.
Idaho is a community property state, which means that in the event of a divorce, the court starts with the presumption that all marital property should be divided equally between the spouses. Marital property includes most assets and debts a couple acquires during their marriage. However, the court has the discretion to depart from an equal division if it finds that such a division would be unjust. When making a determination, the court may consider various factors, including but not limited to each spouse's education, employability, earning capacities, and separate property assets (those acquired before the marriage or by gift/inheritance). The court may also consider whether one spouse's infidelity or abusive behavior contributed to the breakdown of the marriage. Despite the initial presumption of equal division, the actual division of assets in Idaho can be similar to that of equitable distribution states, as the court has the authority to make an unequal division based on the circumstances of the case.